- Paperback
- 368
- What Is Mathematics Really?
- Reuben Hersh
- English
- 19 February 2020
- 9780195130874

## Free read What Is Mathematics Really?

Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Review Ì What Is Mathematics Really? Ê PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Most philosophers of mathematics treat it as isolated timeless ahistorical inhuman Reuben Hersh argues the contrary that mathematics must be understood as a human activity a social phenomenon part of human culture historically evolved and intelligible only in a social context Hersh pulls the screen back to reveal mathematics. In the later chapters it turned or less into a survey of what different philosophers have to say about math Which is nice because you can t just turn up that stuff with a Google search it s a useful surveyBut the book loses the thrust in building an argument that it had earlier And many of the passages seem redundant Also the author attempts to put all philosophers in a modern American political framework who is on the left and the right It s a stretch He decides that those on the left tends to be the ones he agrees with about math It all has a pseudo scientific air about it he s counting up points in an arbitrary fashionFinally in a act reminiscent of Senator John McCain he labels all the philosophers he agrees with mavericksI m not sure he proved anything in this book but I think it s a great source of material for thinking about the subject And I tend to agree with a lot of his conclusions even if I think he took shortcuts to get there Les profs, tome 1. Interro surprise mathematics treat it as isolated timeless ahistorical inhuman Reuben Hersh argues the contrary that "The Dog of My Nightmares: Stories Read by Texas Columnist Dave Lieber" mathematics Andy Catlett: Early Travels: A Novel must be understood as a human activity a social phenomenon part of human culture historically evolved and intelligible only in a social context Hersh pulls the screen back to reveal Capricorne, tome 3 : Deliah mathematics. In the later chapters it turned or less into a survey of what different philosophers have to say about The Fifth Risk eBook: Michael Lewis: Amazon.fr: Amazon Media EUS.à r.l. math Which is nice because you can t just turn up that stuff with a Google search it s a useful surveyBut the book loses the thrust in building an argument that it had earlier And How Science Works: The Facts Visually Explained (How Things Work) many of the passages seem redundant Also the author attempts to put all philosophers in a Classic Sail 2015 Calendar modern American political framework who is on the left and the right It s a stretch He decides that those on the left tends to be the ones he agrees with about The Westing Game (Puffin Modern Classics) math It all has a pseudo scientific air about it he s counting up points in an arbitrary fashionFinally in a act reminiscent of Senator John McCain he labels all the philosophers he agrees with Tom of Finland: The Complete Kake Comics mavericksI Photoshop Down & Dirty Tricks for Designers m not sure he proved anything in this book but I think it s a great source of Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist: Unlocking the Secrets of the Last Supper material for thinking about the subject And I tend to agree with a lot of his conclusions even if I think he took shortcuts to get there

### Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh

Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Review Ì What Is Mathematics Really? Ê PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Nd Russell David Hilbert and Rudolph Carnap followed by the mavericks who saw mathematics as a human artifact including Aristotle Locke Hume Mill and LakatosWhat is Mathematics Really reflects an insider's view of mathematical life and will be hotly debated by anyone with an interest in mathematics or the philosophy of scienc. A nice dense philosophy book written with lots of wit This was NOT a book that you can zone out on and indeed it reuired Full Attention to reap its benefits This meant that I read it in tiny bursts and if before bed would basically immediately fall asleep This would be a good book to sneak into a meditation retreat or to have on a long flighttrain ride or anywhere else it s easy to focus and be alertI was looking for something that talked about the kinda default way everyone thinks about math as being inherently Platonic that is that we think of math as something True beyond human fallibility and human society even This book argues firmly against that Hersh establishes the mainstream philosophy of math as being Platonist but then discusses his humanist belief in math as a socio cultural construct The book is a combination of sly jokesauthor personality which I usually dislike but here really enjoyed he was funny a philosophical discussion using impressively simple examples and then a survey of philosophers from Plato onwards and where they fell on the mainstreammagical math from the eternal cosmos vs humanistmath is just a game and shorthand spectrum He also interestingly framed the mainstream vs humanist philosophy of math as correlating strongly with the right wing vs left wing beliefs of the philosophers themselves and even surprisingly with the fixed mindsetelitism vs growth mindsetmath education is shitty paradigm That last dichotomy was the most surprising and the most eye opening for me It definitely explained my own fraught relationship with math brief bio belowSo I came into the book firmly on the Platonist side I m not Platonist on anything else but I had subconsciously swallowed the mainstream attitudes whole math is magical truth from the cosmos something we discover rather than invent and something that you can either see or not Or as my favorite Leonardo da Vinci uote says there are those who see there are those who see when they are shown and there are those that do not see Magical mathHersh dismantles this argument by noting the ways that math is a social convention collaboratively and imperfectly invented using impossible to totally logically underpin proofs written by real living fallible mathematicians who mostly take it on faith and that many previously held mathematical truths Euclidean space have been dismantled or revised I think this book would have been a bunch enjoyable for actual pureacademic mathematicians since he drops a bunch of stuff I had absolutely zero knowledge of very exotic stuff But his general points he makes concisely and with great wit I also really enjoyed the survey of philosophers I loved the short bios with sarcastic lively interjections boy he really has it in for Wittgenstein haha and I came away from this book with a list of people I keep meaning to read about John Stuart Mill u r a hero jsm John von Neumann also such a hero wow Karl Popper world 3 WORLD 3 what a brilliant idea Bertrand Russell Okay small feminist aside on the surprising way this philosophical argument impacts the mindsetmath education stuff part of the mainstream magical Platonic math mentality is a strong elitism If math is something that s baked into reality s DNA and again not a tool we invented to understand reality s DNA but if it s the actual ahem SOURCE CODE then there are people who can read this codesee these truths and those that can t It matters less how you teach it since there s just One True Math and smart people eventually get there one way or another This of course perpetuates all manner of bad things like how only white dudes have the True Math Sight If you permit me the indulgence I realized recently that my math bio is like a textbook case of stereotype threat In high school I considered myself bad at math but scored a higher math SAT score than my male friend who went on to major in mechanical engineering In college I minored in math and adored every class When I asked my calc 2 prof if I should apply to an applied math master s programs WHAT FUN he discouraged me In grad school I struggled through those goddamn Lagrangians and assumed the struggle was because I was bad at math and not because grad school is grad school In one of my first jobs I figured I d never learn to use Stata the statistical programming language we used well because I was bad at coding and bad at math and didn t think logically I ended up writing the Stata tutorials for staff training lecturing on it and TAing it Now I m a data scientist and I math it up for 40 hrsweek with GREAT PLEASURE and yet I STILL constantly have imposter syndrome and assume I have no natural talent for math and will never be that good at it but am grateful that my joypassion for doing it at least keeps me from totally suckingI mean LOOK AT THAT It s INSANE I have literally mathed with pleasure near constantly since I was 15 and have meanwhile never recognized it as a core part of my identity but instead felt always like an interloper I mean DAMNAnyway so there you go Definitely recommended especially if you like epistemology

**Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary**

Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Review Ì What Is Mathematics Really? Ê PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free As seen by professionals debunking many mathematical myths and demonstrating how the humanist idea of the nature of mathematics closely resembles how mathematicians actually work At the heart of his book is a fascinating historical account of the mainstream of philosophy ranging from Pythagoras Descartes and Spinoza to Bertra. This is an interesting book Hersh weighs in on a debate about the nature of mathematical objects There is Platonism which is the view that mathematical objects are timeless and eternal entities existing independently of any person or society and which we discover as engage in mathematics There are formalists who thinks that mathematical language is just a game we play and the words in it lack any objective reference Hersh puts forth a social historical theory of mathematics which makes it a product of human culture It is not timelessly true some Fregean abstract object in the mind of God But nor is it just a matter of individual opinion since a culture can establish norms that regulate the application and significance of mathematics within that culture Hersh thinks that mathematics will be easier to teach once we root it in lived practice But I cannot accept his thesis Does his thesis entail that 2 2 does not eual 4 independently of a certain culture So if my culture dies off does that mean that 2 2 does not eual four I believe in the Tao so to speak there is just an intelligibility in the universe that does not change with culture I think trying to integrate students into mathematics as humanistic discipline is actually difficult than helping them to discover an abstract structure of the universe Dragon Soul: Cobalt Dragons Book 3 (English Edition) many The God Code:The Secret of our Past, the Promise of our Future mathematical The Columbian Exchange: Biological and Cultural Consequences of 1492, 30th Anniversary Edition myths and demonstrating how the humanist idea of the nature of Josephine A life of the Empress mathematics closely resembles how Spare Parts: Four Undocumented Teenagers, One Ugly Robot, and the Battle for the American Dream mathematicians actually work At the heart of his book is a fascinating historical account of the Liar's Poker: Rising Through the Wreckage on Wall Street mainstream of philosophy ranging from Pythagoras Descartes and Spinoza to Bertra. This is an interesting book Hersh weighs in on a debate about the nature of Character Is Destiny mathematical objects There is Platonism which is the view that Valérian - Tome 3 - Pays sans étoiles (Le) mathematical objects are timeless and eternal entities existing independently of any person or society and which we discover as engage in Intermittent Fasting for Women: The Practical Essentials for Achieving Lasting Weight Loss and Health Results with Intermittent Fasting mathematics There are formalists who thinks that Introducing Statistics: A Graphic Guide (Introducing...), Eileen Magnello, Borin Van Loon - Amazon.com mathematical language is just a game we play and the words in it lack any objective reference Hersh puts forth a social historical theory of Calendario Románico 2019 Mesa mathematics which Terror on the Titanic (Choose Your Own Adventure #24) makes it a product of human culture It is not timelessly true some Fregean abstract object in the Elon Musk: Tesla, Paypal, SpaceX : l'entrepreneur qui va changer le monde / Edition enrichie mind of God But nor is it just a Destinations of a Lifetime: 225 of the World's Most Amazing Places matter of individual opinion since a culture can establish norms that regulate the application and significance of BA-Bauhaus mathematics within that culture Hersh thinks that 2018 - 2019 Daily Planner; Get Shit Done: 18-Month Planner, July 2018 – December 2019, 8”x10” mathematics will be easier to teach once we root it in lived practice But I cannot accept his thesis Does his thesis entail that 2 2 does not eual 4 independently of a certain culture So if La franc-maçonnerie my culture dies off does that Didn't See It Coming mean that 2 2 does not eual four I believe in the Tao so to speak there is just an intelligibility in the universe that does not change with culture I think trying to integrate students into Mighty, Mighty Construction Site mathematics as humanistic discipline is actually difficult than helping them to discover an abstract structure of the universe

Free read What Is Mathematics Really? Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Peace in Troubled TimesFor many including myself mathematics is comforting In an era of fake news worldwide illness and economic un

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary In the later chapters it turned or less into a survey of what different philosophers have to say about math Which is nice because you can't just turn up that stuff with a Google search; it's a useful surveyBut the book loses the thr

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary This book is about philosophy of mathematics not mathematics itself Hersh shows that from the viewpoint of philosophy mathematics must be under

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary Free read What Is Mathematics Really? The book being reviewed here “What is Mathematics Really?” is engagingly written I found the literary style to be high

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh This is an interesting book Hersh weighs in on a debate about the nature of mathematical objects There is Platonism which is the view that mathematical objects are timeless and eternal entities existing independently of any person or society and which we discover as engage in mathematics There are formalists wh

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh Before reading this book I first spent a long time studying its predecessor the book What is Mathematics? And while they both turned out to be uniuely mind blowing Hersh' book in particular has changed my entire world view

Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh ?Hersh sets out to define the parameters of a philosophy of maths his best answer being a socio historiic cultural context resolving the Platonist formalist split the ethereal real zone of Platonism being replaced by the collective human mindbrain The delight of the book though is the later sections on the history of philosophy of maths where he namechecks many's a classic; and the section on basic principles of maths I say basic

EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh Free read ñ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free ô Reuben Hersh A nice dense philosophy book written with lots of wit This was NOT a book that you can zone out on and indeed it reuired Full Attention to reap its benefits This meant that I read it in tiny bursts and if before bed would basically immediately fall asleep This would be a good book to sneak into a meditation retreat or to have on a long flig

Free read What Is Mathematics Really? Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh The book is clearly written well researched and provocative At times Hersh's expositions are clear illustrative and convincing; at times they can be very rushed and in my opinion amateurish The beginning a convers

Free read What Is Mathematics Really? Reuben Hersh ô 2 Summary EBOOK DOWNLOAD [What Is Mathematics Really?] AUTHOR Reuben Hersh That hurt my brain some not actually being a mathematician of any kind But then this isn't math it's the philosophy of math and Hersh's argument that mathematics is a social historical cultural pursuit in opposition to Platonism and formalism the two most popular math philosophies going Knowing little of this world I'd say he makes a good case As a reading experience it gets a bit bogged down in the second half as Hersh